Customer reviews
★★★★★ 4.8 out of 5 from 318 reviews by verified buyers since September 2025.
| 5 stars | 262 |
| 4 stars | 41 |
| 3 stars | 9 |
| 2 stars | 4 |
| 1 stars | 2 |
Reviews are collected by email 14 days after delivery from customers with a completed order. We publish every review, including the critical ones, and never pay or discount for reviews.
Most recent
Grape and caramel, very clean. A crowd pleaser.
Two bags of blends every two weeks for our house. Every box has been good, a couple were great.
Cuts through milk like nothing else. Dialed in within three shots on a Profitec.
Blood orange is not marketing, it is really there. Excellent at 1:2.3.
Switched from grocery store beans and we are not going back. Smooth, chocolatey, never bitter in our Moccamaster. On the 2-week subscription now.
Smells like jasmine the moment you open the bag. Gorgeous in a Kalita.
Finally a light roast my partner likes. Tastes like honey and oranges in a V60.
Tried all four, landed on Hearthstone, now subscribed.
I gave up caffeine last year and have tried every decaf. This is the one.
Rich and round with a pecan sweetness. Roasted 3 days before it arrived.
Blackcurrant jam. If you like bright coffee, buy it.
Third 2 lb bag and my grind setting has barely moved. That consistency is worth a lot.
The origin cards are a nice touch and the coffee is always roasted within days.
Sweet and crisp. My dad, a Folgers lifer, asked what this was.
Brews as well as my plastic V60 and looks a thousand times better.
Read the Huila journal post and then tasted it. Delicious and I like knowing where it came from.
Exactly what I want at 6am. Took a star off because the 5 lb bag is a lot of bag to keep fresh, I split it into jars.
Chocolate and plum, smooth in cold brew too.
Fantastic once dialed, but it punishes a bad grind. Not a beginner espresso.
Wonderful, but not for anyone who likes it dark.
Great flat whites. A little roasty as a straight shot for my taste, I alternate with Lantern.
Coming from a blade grinder, night and day.
Sent to my brother. He loved the tasting card that came with it.
This and a V60 is my Sunday.
We run two batch brewers for about 35 people. Hearthstone is the first coffee nobody has complained about.
Skipped a delivery for vacation with one email. Would like more decaf options.
Tastes like the cortado at my favorite café. The roast date is always within the week.
Good everyday cup, nothing wild.
Easy, sweet, balanced. Would buy the 2 lb again.
A bit thin in my cheap drip machine, fantastic in the Chemex.